The FIRE movement (financial independence, retire early) has a geography problem. A retirement number necessary for a major US city can stretch much further in other cities abroad. That math is why some early retirees leave the country along with their jobs. What doesn’t retire early is their filing obligation.
The IRS Doesn’t Check Your Age
A US citizen who stops working at 40 files under the same rules as one who stops at 65: the requirement follows citizenship and income, not age or address.
Early retirement changes the income sources on that return, not the rules for filing it. Someone living off dividends, rental income, or a taxable brokerage account abroad is still responsible for reporting it to the IRS as they would from a condo in Ohio.
Moving money abroad adds its own paperwork. Foreign bank and brokerage accounts that total more than $10,000 at any point in the year must be reported on an FBAR, and larger balances may also require Form 8938.
Foreign mutual funds and ETFs deserve extra caution: the US generally treats them as passive foreign investment companies, which carry harsh tax rules and their own annual filing.
Foreign Earned Income Exclusion Doesn’t Apply Here
Many FIRE expats assume the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion will shelter their income the way it sheltered a paycheck. It won’t. The exclusion only applies to earned income, wages or self-employment pay for active work.
Dividends, capital gains, rental income, and withdrawals from retirement accounts are all unearned income, and none of it qualifies. An early retiree living entirely off investment income may find the exclusion does nothing for their return at all.
The tool that usually has a bigger impact is the foreign tax credit. When the country of residence taxes the same income, a credit for those foreign taxes can reduce or eliminate the US tax on it, though how well it works depends on the country’s rates and the type of income.
Roth Conversions Get More Complicated
Early retirees frequently use Roth conversion ladders to reach retirement funds before 59½. Each year, part of a traditional IRA is converted to a Roth. The converted amount is taxable income on the US return that year, and after five years it can be withdrawn without the 10% early withdrawal penalty.
Living abroad adds a wrinkle. The country of residence may tax the conversion too, and some countries don’t recognize the tax-free status of Roth accounts at all, so withdrawals that are tax-free in the US can still be taxed locally. The tax treaty, if one exists, may or may not resolve the conflict.
Health Coverage Changes the Budget
FIRE plans built around US healthcare costs often get revised once someone moves. Private insurance or public healthcare abroad is frequently cheaper, which can improve the retirement math considerably. But it also means the retiree is outside the ACA marketplace, and any assumptions about subsidies or premium tax credits built into the original plan no longer apply.
State Residency Rarely Ends on Its Own
An early retiree who sold the house and left the country may still owe state income tax if the state doesn’t consider them to have formally severed residency. California, New York, and a handful of other states are notably aggressive about this. Filing a federal return while ignoring the state side is a common and expensive oversight.
Early Withdrawal Penalties Still Apply
Tapping a 401(k) or traditional IRA before 59½ generally triggers the 10% early withdrawal penalty, no matter where the retiree lives or what their revised cost of living looks like. There are exceptions, such as substantially equal periodic payments, and each has strict rules. The Roth conversion ladder described above works differently; it avoids the penalty by waiting out the five-year clock on each conversion. FIRE plans built around early withdrawals need to account for this from the start, not discover it at tax time.
An early retirement date doesn’t change what the IRS expects, and an unfamiliar country doesn’t come with a manual for how the two systems interact. Smith Patrick works with expats around the world and can review a retirement strategy before the first year of filing from a new address. Contact Smith Patrick to talk through what early retirement abroad looks like on a tax return.
More Information
If you have questions, contact us to discuss your situation.
To check out our other articles on business topics, click here.

David Smith
David Smith helps businesses and individuals develop smart business practices for tax and accounting advantages as the president of Smith Patrick CPAs. He is involved in the cannabis industry in Missouri through MoCannTrade and other organizations, helping cannabis operators with their tax and accounting needs.
About Smith Patrick CPAs
Smith Patrick CPAs is a boutique, St. Louis-based, CPA firm dedicated to providing personal guidance on taxes, investment advice and financial service to forward-thinking businesses and financially active individuals. For over 30 years, our firm has focused on providing excellent service to business owners and high-net worth families across the country. Investment Advisory Services are offered through Wealth Management, LLC, a Registered Investment Advisor.